5 Unexpected Ingredients That Pair Beautifully with Bourbon

Surprising Flavors That Bring Out the Best in Your Favorite Pour

When you think of bourbon pairings, you probably picture classics like dark chocolate, pecan pie, or a juicy steak. But this bold, versatile spirit has a wild side—and it plays surprisingly well with some unexpected flavors. Whether you’re crafting cocktails, curating a tasting menu, or just experimenting at home, these five ingredients bring out bourbon’s hidden layers in the most delicious ways.

🥭 1. Mango

Yes, really. The bright, tropical sweetness of mango offers a juicy contrast to bourbon’s warm, oaky base. Muddle it into a cocktail, infuse it into a syrup, or serve fresh slices alongside a neat pour. The fruitiness lifts bourbon’s deeper notes, especially in a summery smash or punch.

Try It In: A mango bourbon sour with lime juice and honey syrup.

🧀 2. Blue Cheese

Bourbon and… blue cheese? Absolutely. The tangy, salty funk of blue cheese cuts through bourbon’s caramel sweetness, creating a luxurious pairing that lingers on the palate. Serve it on a charcuterie board with candied pecans and a bourbon cocktail, and watch your guests’ eyebrows rise—in a good way.

Try It With: A bold, high-proof bourbon and a wedge of gorgonzola.

🌿 3. Rosemary

This savory herb may be more at home with roast chicken, but it brings a refreshing, aromatic twist to bourbon cocktails. Use rosemary simple syrup, torch a sprig for garnish, or shake it into a citrus-forward drink for a sophisticated, herbal edge.

Try It In: A bourbon rosemary fizz with grapefruit juice and soda water.

🍄 4. Mushrooms

Umami and bourbon? Surprisingly elegant. The earthy depth of mushrooms enhances the barrel-aged richness of bourbon, especially when paired in a savory dish or infused into bitters or syrups. Think bourbon-glazed mushroom crostini or a mushroom risotto with a bourbon butter finish.

Try It With: A mushroom-forward appetizer and a glass of Left Bank on the rocks.

🍯 5. Spicy Honey

Sweet heat is one of bourbon’s best friends. Spicy honey—infused with chili or pepper—brings a zesty kick that accentuates bourbon’s spice notes while balancing its sweetness. Drizzle it over fried chicken, stir it into a cocktail, or pair it with cornbread and a dram.

Try It In: A spicy honey old fashioned with orange bitters and a dash of cayenne.

🥃 Final Sip

Bourbon is a spirit with depth, warmth, and surprising flexibility. Whether you're entertaining or just treating yourself, don’t be afraid to explore beyond the usual pairings. These bold combinations might just lead you to your new favorite pour.

At Left Bank, we believe great bourbon is meant to be shared—and sometimes, experimented with. Cheers to the unexpected.